This legal overview for beginner software developers will help answer. In addition, aspects of competition law and public procurement law are also examined broadly. If you want to grant users legal access to your software, ship it with a license agreement or, to be more exact, with an offer to conclude a contract that grants the user a license to play your. Its perfectly legal to sell a modified version of gpl at least v2, im not as familiar with v3 software. Not all open source software is distributed under the same type of licensing agreement. The fsfes annual free software legal and licensing workshop llw took place from 18 to 20 april, in barcelona, spain. Unless absolutely required, avoid custom, modified, or nonstandard terms, which will serve as a barrier to downstream use of the agency code. The linux kernel is licensed under the gnu general public license, version 2. The complex legal aspects of software license agreements are addressed in this final part of a threepart series. The intricacies of using the gpl license have been hashed out repeatedly in many other forums. The licensor is the party granting the license often but. Software and saas software as a service vendors can, however, minimize the friction. When small software vendors contract with large companies, the balance of power almost always favors the enterprise. Software as a service saas arrangements are increasingly replacing onsite software licensing for many it applications.
This program will address the critical issues that companies face with respect to the use of open source software in business including intellectual property and licensing issues, as well as issues. Legal issues arising from use of open source software. An introduction to the legal issues surrounding open. In any data licensing transaction, a key negotiated point is accounting for the licensors ownership of and the licensees permitted use of the data. Why you need a software license agreement as a software developer, you have likely spent a lot of time and money developing the software you are wishing to license. Software licensing agreement legal issues involving dishonesty. This article was adapted from an article authored by chris peters in march 2009. The party licensing out the data, whether it is a vendor or customer, should ensure the agreement accurately addresses its ownership of or other rights in the data by. Common open source software legal issues are explained below. Dont use license agreements for software as a service. However, to skilfully negotiate and draft saas agreements, counsel must understand not only the legal issues that are common to software license. Guide to legal and ethical use of software washington. An introduction to the legal issues surrounding open source.
High court rules for sap, against diageo in indirect. By contrast, the gnu general publ ic license is intended to guarantee your freedom to share and change free software to make sure the software is free for all its users. The most significant effect of this form of licensing is that, if ownership of the software remains with the software publisher, then the enduser must accept the software license. Frequently the creator of the software wishes to maintain control and therefore gives a license rather than selling ownership of the software. Implementation of all the decisions of the commission relating to legal issues. The high court in london has ruled in favour of sap and against diageo in an indirect licensing case concerning the use of mysap enterprise resource planning erp software on a salesforce platform. Software license agreements raise a number of issues for both licensors and licensees. Dec 11, 2012 a good example of oss is drupal in all its forms, including drupal mobile. Data security, privacy, service performance, intellectual property ownership, business operations and customer service are a few of the many issues that businesses may encounter when negotiating software license and saas contracts. If you want to grant users legal access to your software, ship it with a license agreement or, to be more exact, with an offer to conclude a contract that grants the user a license to play your game. This typically means entering a software licensing agreement. This attitude can cause a lot of problems for the vendor, because ip, arguably, makes. Data issues often arise as an ancillary issue in software and other technology product and service agreements, such as license agreements, software as a service saas agreements and hosting agreements. Saas contracts should not use licenses to software.
The license shall not restrict any party from selling or giving away the software as a component of an aggregate software distribution containing programs from several different sources. What to consider when signing a licensing agreement for your. What if i want to change the license of my project. Which open source license is appropriate for my project. The constantly evolving legal, technical and regulatory landscape drives the need to stay current in a wide variety of key areas. The infringement of software, or software piracy, is illegal in many countries. And granting a license could cause problems for the saas vendor.
Learn more about software licensing, contracts, intellectual property, and other legal issues at. Set forth below is the first part of a quick checklist of issues customers should be mindful of in any software licensing agreement. Understanding open source legal issues and practical. Enterprise software licensing from a legal perspective findlaw. Use of oss components when creating proprietary software seems like an obvious choice someone else has done all the work hence a saving in development effort and costs, and. A standardized license serves as a proxy for those without legal training to know precisely what they can and cant do with the software. Finally, he is the founder of tech contracts academy and our primary trainer.
Software licensing is a complicated topic, but knowing a little about software licensing can help you make sense of all that fine print. His practice focuses on software licenses, cloud computing agreements, and other it transactions. After all, most people in such positions are well educated and used to dealing with multiple projects having many details in the. Reading the term restriction above, you might be forgiven for jumping to. To learn about specific microsoft server and client licensing scenarios, see an introduction to microsoft server and client licensing. Software licensing presents issues, challenges for enterprises. Ninth circuit issues important decision on software. The free software legal and licensing workshop 2018. Here are some highlights of a few specific issues that come up occasionaly. These arizona cases show that legal liability reaching over the sixfigure mark are possible outcomes. Software licensing in the cloud when a customer controls clouddeployed applications, the software licensing issues can get complicated. Legal and licensing division performs, in short, the following duties and responsibilities. These software licensing agreement legal issues can often be prevented with an ironclad license that clearly states what the licensee can and cannot doand provides sufficient penalties for violating the license that even a dishonest customer will think twice before engaging in. The software licensing dilemma cwsl scholarly commons.
This gener al public license applies to most of the free software foundations software. The legal basics of software licensing techrepublic. Unfortunately, in order to get our work done quickly and conveniently, some people make and use unauthorized software copies. Here is an example that i have encountered in my practice. Legal issues in licensing electronic resources association. Insofar as contract law is concerned, license contracts pertaining to. Software license agreements are used when a proprietary software. Open source licensing and legal issues open source licences can be a source of some confusion. Contract corner software license checklist for licensees. Riley is a partner in the law firm of mcguirewoods llp, based in chicago, ill. Encountering common technology contracts managed service.
Licenses for oss come in different forms, and they all offer different terms of usage. Why do people care so much about the legal side of open source. Keep in mind these software settlements were reported in 2003, so the. Software and saas software as a service vendors can, however, minimize the friction in the procurement process by understanding recent trends in enterprise software licensing and following a few recommendations. Lawsuit threatens to break new ground on the gpl and.
Sample software license agreement provisions findlaw. Home software ninth circuit issues important decision on software licensing practices and web scraping. Legal issues critical in software license agreements. This article discusses some of the most important issues and includes a model license. Microsoft manages legal and ethical issues introduction when bill gates and paul allen founded microsoft in 1975, they had no idea that their company would become the worlds leading supplier of software. When versata software sued ameriprise financial services for breaching its software license, it unwittingly unearthed a gpl violation of its own and touched off another lawsuit that could prove to be a leading case on free and open source software licensing. Dont use license agreements for softwareasaservice.
However the best article i found, dont use license agreements for software as a service written by david w. This structure presumes licensing is the appropriate form of agreement it is much less common, but another party may require the transfer of ownership of the software. These software licensing agreement legal issues can often be prevented with an ironclad license that clearly states what the licensee can and cannot doand provides sufficient penalties for violating the license. The free software legal and licensing workshop fsfe legal. The legal issues surrounding software licensing and saas software as a service agreements are just about as complex and dynamic as the development of the software itself.
Lawsuit threatens to break new ground on the gpl and software. Bas nabulsi and sean macdavitt speak on legal issues in software licensing at the stamford innovation center in stamford, ct. Legal and operational issues with business consequences. In 2018 workshop gathered ca 120 top legal experts from all over the world and included more than 40 presentations on wide variety of legal issues. Ninth circuit issues important decision on software licensing. Choosing the wrong type of software licensing or saas agreement can have a dramatic, lasting impact on your ability to capitalize on your software, so its important to. Software licensing transactions are more complex and more important than ever. Intellectual property ip is a piece of work that isnt a tangible object. A guide to the ethical and legal use of software for members of the academic community. Ip usually comes from creativity and could be could be a manuscript, a formula, a song, or software. Whats worse, a stunning number of small businesses dont just use unlicensed software, theyre absolutely crazy about the stuff. Giving legal advice on all matters as per requirement of the commission. Legal issues on free software and license contracts.
Even in countries where there are not legal measures in place for the protection of ed software, there are some compelling ethical issues that may be considered both for and against software. For more information on data licensing, see practical law s practice note, data as ip and data license agreements this look at the major issues on the horizon for corporate counsel comes from practical law an online legal. Confidentiality and data issues in software licenses. The basics of software license agreements legalnature. A software license agreement is something you want to have in place to prevent or protect you from infringement of law.
Licenses and your rights a license allows an intellectual property rights holder the licensor to make money from an invention or creative work by charging a user the licensee for the products use. Microsoft manages legal and ethical issues introduction when bill gates and paul allen founded microsoft in 1975, they had no idea that their company would become the worlds leading supplier of software for personal computers. Choosing the wrong type of software licensing or saas agreement can have a dramatic, lasting impact on your ability to capitalize on your software. Unfortunately, in order to get our work done quickly and conveniently, some people make and use unauthorized software. This event has become the worlds foremost gathering of lawyers, technologists and thought leaders on free software legal and licensing.
The eclipse public license epl is an open source software license used by eclipse foundation for its software. You can change the source code or even change its mode of operation. Understanding software license and services agreements. Apr 12, 2018 how to address software licensing agreement legal issues. Performing legal vetting on proposed agreements and contracts. Whether you are faced with a software audit, struggling with software license compliance, or engaging in software licensing. Yet, the legal theories that apply to them remain the same. Gain a better understanding of legal and security issues with open source software. Migrating software applications to the cloud can have significant cost and operational advantages. Dont use license agreements for softwareasaservice tech. Enterprise software licensing from a legal perspective.
This post takes a look at the legal issues raised by both cases and what they mean for foss producers and users. Understanding software license and services agreements james b. A checklist to aid in negotiating a licensing agreement, much less to aid in actually preparing and writing the agreement itself, may sound like a simplistic tool to an experienced negotiator or contract attorney. Making sense of software licensing articles and howtos. Understanding the technological aspects of the transaction allows attorneys to apply correct legal terms. What are some of the issues to consider in a licensing agreement. If you want to grant users legal access to your software, ship it with a license agreement or, to be more exact, with an offer to conclude a contract. Take the complexity of technology and stir in the jargon of the legal system and what do you get. He advises zeroturnaround in intellectual property and legal matters. Software enables us to accomplish many different tasks with computers.
However, you must still comply with the terms of the license you must offer the source code, including your modifications, if the modifications fall under the definition of a derivative work, which it seems likely they do from your brief description. The free software legal and licensing workshop is held every year to allow legal experts to discuss issues and best practices surrounding free software licences. Everything youve ever wondered about the legal side of open source, and a few things you didnt. Sample software license agreement provisions findlaw are you a legal professional. This program will address the critical issues that companies face with respect to the use of open source software in business including intellectual property and licensing issues, as well as issues that may arise. He is an attorney, expert witness, and the founder of sycamore legal, p. This article addresses some of the fundamental issues that licensors and licensees. Ip indemnification and related remedies in software licensing. Use of oss components when creating proprietary software seems like an obvious choice someone else has done all the work hence a saving in development effort and costs, and the components are free to use. However, this does not mean that it does not have any legal issues. The structure and context of every software license is different depending on the needs of the parties. Todays items focus on issues that are more business or operational in nature, while the forthcoming post with part 2 of the checklist will include more traditional legal issues. An introduction to the legal issues surrounding open source software by daliah saper saper law offices, llc 505 n. This article is a general introduction to software licensing.
623 1228 1395 863 272 424 1036 686 1549 631 1624 347 393 1089 282 940 598 1124 1430 1609 170 1035 1229 76 578 1568 1070 1305 1379 992 938 1092 813 596 84 153 175 371 861 1091 780 1215 778 83 474 1264